What to Do When One Partner Loves the Holidays, and the Other Doesn’t

The holiday season is often considered the most wonderful time of the year—filled with festive cheer, decorations, and special moments with family and friends. However, for some couples, the excitement isn’t mutual. If one partner is thrilled about the holidays and the other finds them overwhelming, stressful, or even a little draining, it can create tension in the relationship. Finding a way to balance your differing levels of enthusiasm is key to maintaining harmony. Here’s how you can navigate this tricky situation while ensuring that your relationship stays strong, and everyone’s needs are respected.

Acknowledge and Validate Each Other’s Feelings

The first step is to have an open conversation about your differing feelings toward the holidays. Whether one partner loves the festive decorations, the social events, or the gift-giving tradition, while the other finds it stressful or overwhelming, it’s important to validate each other’s emotions. For the partner who isn’t as keen on the holiday cheer, it’s crucial to acknowledge that your feelings are valid too. Not everyone associates the holidays with happiness—some may feel stressed due to financial pressures, family obligations, or past difficult experiences. For the partner who is excited about the season, it’s equally important to understand and empathize with their partner’s perspective.

Find Compromises That Work for Both

Finding common ground is essential. While one partner might enjoy the bustling holiday parties, the other might prefer quiet time together. One of the best ways to compromise is by allowing each other the space to enjoy the season in your own way. For example, agree on certain key activities that both partners can enjoy, like a cozy night watching holiday movies, or taking a walk to see the local holiday lights. At the same time, allow your partner who enjoys the festivities to take part in social events, while the other partner takes a break and does something they enjoy separately. Remember, compromise doesn’t mean complete sacrifice on either side, but finding a balance that feels fair.

Set Boundaries and Communicate Needs

Setting boundaries is crucial when your holiday experiences are different. One of the main sources of tension during this time of year is the overwhelming number of obligations. If one partner is excited to participate in every event and gathering, but the other feels drained by socializing, it’s essential to discuss and respect boundaries.

If your partner doesn’t want to attend every family gathering or office party, it’s okay for them to communicate that. You can attend the events that matter most to you, while giving them the freedom to skip certain activities. Having a clear understanding of what each person is comfortable with will alleviate any misunderstandings or hurt feelings.

Compromise on Holiday Traditions

In couples where one person loves the holidays and the other doesn’t, the question of holiday traditions can cause friction. For example, one partner may want to decorate the house top-to-bottom with festive ornaments, while the other partner may feel overwhelmed by the clutter. Or perhaps one person is eager to host family events, while the other would prefer a quieter time. To manage this, have a conversation early on about which traditions are most meaningful to each of you and decide how you want to integrate those traditions in a way that honors both of your needs. For example, you could alternate who takes charge of certain aspects of holiday planning, such as who hosts the annual dinner or where you spend Christmas Day.

Politely and Lovingly Hold Boundaries on Overwhelm

As the holiday season can be overwhelming for both partners, especially when there are high expectations, it’s important to politely and lovingly hold boundaries. Whether you need a night to recharge or want to skip a holiday obligation, communicate it respectfully. When the holidays get hectic, it can be easy to lose sight of individual needs. But it’s important for both partners to take breaks from the holiday hustle and bustle.  For example, if your partner is insistent on attending every possible holiday event but you feel overwhelmed by all the obligations, be honest and kind about your need for a break. You could say something like, “I really enjoy spending time with your family, but I’m feeling drained, and I need a quiet night in tonight to recharge.” This kind of respectful honesty helps prevent resentment and helps both partners feel heard.

Focus on the Bigger Picture: Connection, Not Perfection

In relationships, especially during the holidays, it’s easy to get caught up in the idea of making everything perfect. Whether it’s the perfect gift, the ideal holiday dinner, or the dream vacation, focusing on creating memorable moments together is more important than achieving perfection. If the holidays are stressing you out as a couple, refocus on what matters most: spending quality time together and connecting emotionally. Even if you’re not doing everything traditionally or in the way one person might have envisioned, what matters is your shared experience.

When one partner loves the holidays and the other doesn’t, it’s essential to communicate openly, compromise, and be respectful of each other’s needs and boundaries. By finding a balance and setting realistic expectations, you can navigate the holiday season without letting it create tension in your relationship. The key to enjoying the holidays together is prioritizing connection, compromise, and respect. Whether you celebrate big or small, create new traditions, or simply enjoy the peace of a quiet winter day, your bond will grow stronger when you approach the season as a team.